Awards Archive: 2017 - 2021
2017
| AWARD | WINNER | TEAM |
| Pro League Most Valuable Player | Joey Dolce | Parker Prowlers |
| Pro Top Scorer | Ryen Pezzola | New Jersey Grizzlies |
| Pro Most Valuable Goaltender | Pat Bell | Pittsburgh Inferno |
| Pro Playoff Most Valuable Player | Matt Gerger | Pittsburgh Inferno |
| Organization of the Year | New Jersey Grizzlies |
2018
| AWARD | WINNER | TEAM |
| Pro League Most Valuable Player | Tyler Kraft | Suffolk Sting |
| Pro Top Scorer | Jake Miller | Colorado Springs Thunder |
| Pro Most Valuable Goaltender | Robb Woods | Parker Prowlers |
| Pro Playoff Most Valuable Player | BIlly Pascalli | Suffolk Sting |
| Unsung Hero | Daniel Fierro | PIHA Columbia |
| Coach of the Year | Joe Luzinski | Ft Collins Jawz |
| Organization of the Year | Lakewood Fire |
2019
| AWARD | WINNER | TEAM |
| Pro League Most Valuable Player | CJ Bateman | Parker Prowlers |
| Pro Top Scorer | KJ Tiefenwerth | Suffolk Sting |
| Pro Most Valuable Goaltender | Mike Maczynski | Suffolk Sting |
| Pro Playoff Most Valuable Player | Joey DiMartino | Suffolk Sting |
| Unsung Hero | Rob Coggin | USARS |
| Coach of the Year | John Bovee | Parker Prowlers |
| Organization of the Year | Delco Demons |
2020
| AWARD | WINNER | TEAM |
| Pro League Most Valuable Player | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| Pro Top Scorer | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| Pro Most Valuable Goaltender | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| Pro Playoff Most Valuable Player | Brett Jackson | Suffolk Sting |
| Unsung Hero | Jarrett Lazor | Colorado Springs Thunder |
| Coach of the Year | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| Organization of the Year | Not Awarded |
2021
| AWARD | WINNER | TEAM |
| Pro League Most Valuable Player | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| Pro Top Scorer | Jake Townsend | Denver Dragonfly |
| Pro Most Valuable Goaltender | Not Awarded | Not Awarded |
| Pro Playoff Most Valuable Player | Tommy Nostramo | Suffolk Sting |
| Unsung Hero | Chris Roche | PIHA |
| Coach of the Year | Mike Gerger | Pittsburgh Inferno |
| Organization of the Year | Philadelphia Liberty |